← All guides

Should You Put the Link in the First Comment?

· 10 min read · by Jan Oršula

Only on some platforms, and less often than the advice suggests. On LinkedIn, a link in the first comment is a sensible default for a post that stands on its own, because outside data keeps showing lower reach for link posts and LinkedIn has never ruled that out. Facebook changed the question in late 2026 for the Pages it's testing a link limit on: two clickable links a month on the free plan, with links in comments counting too. If your Page has the limit, the choice is which posts get a link at all. On X and Threads, keep the link in the post: both have said publicly that link posts aren't held back any more. On Instagram, TikTok and YouTube Shorts, a link in a comment can't be clicked at all, so the first comment is the wrong place for it.

The rest of this guide goes platform by platform: what the company itself has said (with dates), what independent tests found, whether a comment link is even clickable, and what it costs you. Then the timing problem nobody mentions, a test you can run on your own account, and a simple rule for when the link stays in the post.

The first comment in Kadenzo, posted seconds after the post goes live. 48 seconds.

The short answer, platform by platform

Has the platform said links cost reach?Can people click a link in a comment?What to do
LinkedInNever confirmed or denied; outside studies measure lower reachYesFirst comment for posts that stand alone
XSaid yes in 2024, says no since mid-2025YesKeep the link in the post
FacebookNo stated rule; some Pages now have a monthly link allowanceYes, but on capped Pages comment links countFirst comment if your Page isn't capped; otherwise save links for posts where the click matters
ThreadsSays link posts are ranked normally since mid-2025YesKeep the link in the post
InstagramNot the issue: captions and comments don't linkNoBio link, Story link sticker or a DM
TikTokNot the issue: captions and comments don't linkNoBio link
YouTubeNot the issue on long videosLong videos yes, Shorts noDescription, plus a pinned comment

Kadenzo first comments

The comment goes up seconds after the post

Write a different first comment for each network in the same draft, on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn and Threads. Every plan, from $19 a month.

See how it works

LinkedIn: a reasonable default, with one catch

LinkedIn has never published a rule that demotes posts with outside links, and it hasn't denied one either. What exists is outside data, and it points the same way year after year. Richard van der Blom's yearly Algorithm Insights report has measured lower reach for posts with a single external link for several editions running. Ordinal, a LinkedIn scheduling company, analysed posts from 2023 to early 2026 and put the median reach gap at about 26.5%, with most of it landing on company pages rather than personal profiles. Agorapulse's Social Media Lab tested the workaround itself and found no sign that LinkedIn punished posts whose link sat in the comments.

So the first comment still looks like the safer spot on LinkedIn. The catch is how you announce it. In March 2026 LinkedIn said it is cutting back on "comment to agree" prompts and on posts "designed purely to game distribution." A post whose only job is to say "link in the comments" fits that description uncomfortably well. So write a post that is useful on its own, and mention the comment once, in the last line.

Two LinkedIn details people miss. A comment link gets fewer clicks than the same link in the post, because many readers never open the comments, so the reach you gain isn't all clicks. And because LinkedIn decides a post's spread in its first hour, the comment has to be there from the first minute (more on that below). For how that first hour works, see how the LinkedIn algorithm works.

X is the one platform where the company has spoken plainly, and changed its answer.

  • October 2023: Elon Musk said the algorithm optimizes for time spent on X, so links get less attention.
  • November 24, 2024: Musk told Paul Graham to write the description in the main post and put the link in the reply, to "stop lazy linking." That reply is where most link-in-reply advice comes from.
  • October 2025: Nikita Bier, X's head of product, said links weren't being deboosted, but did get lower engagement because the in-app browser covers the post and people forget to like or reply. X started testing a link view on iOS that keeps the post's buttons visible.
  • July 28–29, 2026: Bier told Mark Zuckerberg he no longer needed to put links in replies, and Musk added: "We haven't for over a year."

Take the company at its word and the reply trick no longer buys reach on X. The reason links underperformed (people leave and don't come back to like) is still real, so give people a reason to engage before they tap: put the point of the link in the post, not just the URL. A reply is still useful when a long URL would crowd a short post, but it costs clicks, because fewer people see a reply than the post above it.

Meta has never stated a link penalty either, but its own numbers make the case. In Meta's Widely Viewed Content Report for Q2 2025, 97.8% of US Feed views went to posts with no link to anything outside Facebook. In June 2025, Social Media Today spotted a Professional Dashboard tip on Page posts suggesting the link go somewhere other than the post itself, which the outlet called "kind of" official.

In December 2025 Meta started testing a cap on link posts for Pages and profiles in professional mode. By October 2026 the cap had become part of Meta One, Meta's paid subscription for businesses, and it now counts comments as well. As Engadget and others report it, the free plan allows two posts or comments with an outside link a month, and the allowance resets on the 1st. Once it's used up, you can still post a link, but nobody can click it. Meta One Advanced raises the allowance to 8 a month, Expert to 20 and Max to unlimited. Links to Meta's own surfaces (a Facebook event, a group, an Instagram profile) don't count, and neither do links in ads. A Meta spokesperson still calls it something Meta has "been testing", and plenty of Pages don't have the limit at all: on 16 November 2026 our own Page's composer showed no counter or notice. So check your Page before you change anything.

If your Page doesn't have the limit, the first comment still works the old way. If it does, the comment no longer saves you anything: it spends the same allowance as a link in the post. So decide which two posts a month deserve a link (the Facebook link limit guide covers what counts and whether paying for more is worth it), and give them to the ones where the click is the point: a launch, a sale, a sign-up deadline. Make everything else work without the click, with a photo, a short video or a real paragraph, or point people to a Facebook event or group, which doesn't use up the allowance. Facebook Groups are a different case: the group's own rules decide, and plenty of groups ban links outright.

Threads: keep the link in the post

Threads used to be vague about links. In June 2025 Adam Mosseri said the team had been "making sure links are ranked properly" and that links had been "working much better for more than a month." Threads also added up to five profile links in May 2025. There's no penalty left to dodge, so a link in the post is the simpler choice, and it's the one people actually see.

A reply under your own post is still handy for a second link or for credits. Links in Threads replies are clickable.

Instagram: the comment isn't the answer

Links in Instagram captions and comments show as plain text, so a link in the first comment just sends people copying a URL by hand. (Since March 2026 Meta has been testing clickable caption links for some Meta Verified subscribers, with a monthly cap, but most accounts don't have it.)

The working routes are the bio link, a link sticker in Stories, and a keyword people comment to get the link by DM. Our link in bio strategy covers what that one link should point to. The first comment on Instagram is still useful for credits, a question to start the comments or extra context; for hashtags, see where hashtags go now, because that advice changed.

TikTok and YouTube: quick notes

  • TikTok: links in captions and comments aren't clickable. The link goes in your bio, and the video says "link in bio."
  • YouTube long videos: links in the description and in comments are clickable. Put the link in the description, then pin a comment that repeats it for people who read comments first.
  • YouTube Shorts: since August 31, 2023, links in Shorts comments and descriptions aren't clickable. YouTube made the change to cut spam. Point Shorts viewers to a long video or your channel links instead.

A link in the first comment helps only if it's there when the first viewers arrive. Those first minutes are when the platform shows your post to a small group and watches what they do. If the post says "link in the comments" and the comment isn't up yet, the people who wanted the link leave, and some of them reply "where's the link?", which is the last thing you want your first comment to be.

That's why the manual routine (publish, then rush to post the comment yourself) works only when you're at your desk at publish time. A post scheduled for 8:30 while you're on the school run gets its link comment at 9:10, after the window that mattered. Editing the link into the post later doesn't fix it either.

So people automate it. A scheduler can post the comment seconds after the post goes live, from the same draft, so the two can't drift apart.

studio.kadenzo.app
Kadenzo's composer with a LinkedIn post in the caption editor, a marker where LinkedIn will cut the post with see more, and the LinkedIn First Comment field below holding a link to the full checklist.
The post stands on its own. The link waits in the first comment and goes out seconds after the post.

In Kadenzo, the first comment works on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn and Threads on every plan. It goes out as its own request a few seconds after the post, with its own retries, so a problem with the comment never holds up the post. You can set a different comment per network in the same draft: the link on LinkedIn, a question on Threads, the credits on Instagram. On Facebook, a link in the first comment uses Meta's monthly link allowance just like one in the post, so keep it for the posts you've picked. The first comment automation page shows it in action.

On X, Kadenzo has a First Reply for single posts, on the Professional plan ($29 a month) and up. It's posted once, right after the post. If it fails, the post stays up and the reply isn't retried, so nothing ever posts twice. A link in the reply counts toward your X link posts exactly like a link in the post, because X's API charges for posts with links. Given what X now says about links, the reply is mostly for keeping a short post clean, not for reach.

studio.kadenzo.app
Kadenzo's composer with an X post and the First Reply field open underneath, holding one line and a link.
On X, the First Reply posts under your post straight away. A link in it counts toward your monthly X link posts.

Test it on your own account

Studies average thousands of accounts. Yours may behave differently, and the test takes about a month.

  1. Pick one platform and one kind of post, for example LinkedIn posts that share a new article.
  2. Alternate: five posts with the link in the post, five with the link in the first comment, mixed across the same weekdays and times.
  3. Tag every link with a UTM builder, using utm_content=in-post or utm_content=first-comment, so your web analytics show which placement sent visits.
  4. Compare two numbers per post: impressions from the platform, and sessions from your analytics.
  5. Decide on clicks, not reach. If the comment versions reach more people but send fewer visits, the post was doing its job better with the link in it.

Ten posts won't give you a scientific answer, but a gap that shows up in eight of the ten is worth acting on.

When to keep the link in the post

Use one test: if the post makes sense without the link, the link can go in the first comment. If the post is pointless without it, keep it in the post.

In practice, keep the link in the post when:

  • The click is the whole point: a launch, a sale ending tonight, a sign-up deadline, a news story. Burying the link costs more clicks than any reach gain returns.
  • You post on X or Threads. Both say link posts are ranked normally, so a comment only hides the link.
  • The preview card is the content, like an article headline and image people recognize.
  • You're boosting the post as an ad. Paid reach doesn't care where organic advice puts the link, and ad formats expect it in the post.
  • The platform can't click a comment link (Instagram, TikTok, Shorts). Then neither spot works, and the bio or description does the job.

Everything else, the posts that teach, tell a story or make an argument and offer the link as "more", can carry the link one line below on LinkedIn. On Facebook, the same goes for Pages without the link limit; a capped Page should save its two links for the posts where the click is the point. For the wider question of turning posts into visits, see how to drive traffic from social media.

Kadenzo first comments

The link lands in the first comment while you're somewhere else

Schedule the post and its first comment together on LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram and Threads, with a different comment per network. Plans start at $19 a month.

See plans and pricing

Frequently asked questions

Why do people put links in the comments on LinkedIn?

Because outside studies keep finding that LinkedIn posts with an external link reach fewer people, and LinkedIn has never said otherwise. The comment keeps the post itself link-free. The trade-off is fewer clicks, since many readers never open the comments.

How do I add a link in a LinkedIn comment?

Paste the full URL, including https://, into the comment and post it. It becomes clickable. Add one short line saying what the link is, so the comment reads as useful rather than as a bare URL.

Can I put a clickable link in an Instagram comment?

No. Links in Instagram comments and in most captions show as plain text. Use the link in your bio, a link sticker in a Story, or ask people to comment a keyword and send them the link by DM.

Can you put a link in a TikTok or YouTube Shorts comment?

You can type one, but nobody can tap it. TikTok captions and comments don't turn URLs into links, and YouTube stopped making links in Shorts comments and descriptions clickable in August 2023. On long YouTube videos, comment and description links do work.

Does X still penalize posts with links?

X says it doesn't. In July 2026 its head of product told Mark Zuckerberg he no longer needed to put links in replies, and Elon Musk said X hadn't penalized link posts for over a year. Link posts can still get fewer likes, because people leave to read the page.

How do I schedule the first comment on Instagram or Facebook?

Use a scheduler that posts the first comment for you. Write the comment in the same draft as the post, and it goes out seconds after the post is live. In Kadenzo it works on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn and Threads on every plan.

How many links can a Facebook Page post per month?

If your Page is in Meta's link limit, two posts or comments with a link to an outside site on the free plan, reset on the 1st of each month, as reported in late 2026. Pages outside it have no cap. Meta One Advanced allows 8, Expert 20 and Max unlimited. Links to Facebook events, groups and Instagram don't count, and neither do ads. Meta still calls it a test, so check the notice on your own Page.

Should I write "link in the comments" in my post?

Only as a last line under a post that's useful on its own. LinkedIn has said it shows fewer posts built to game distribution, and a post that exists only to point at a comment looks like one. Make sure the comment is already there when people read the line.